Best Pet Insurance for Dogs
Five carriers compared on the terms that decide a dog's claims: the orthopedic waiting period, exam fees, direct vet payment and what happens as the dog ages.
By Marin Okafor, editor, dog gear and nutrition labels
Published Aug 30, 2026 · 13 min read
- Pet Insurance
- 5 products compared
In this guide
Dog policies are close to identical on the things buyers compare and wildly different on the thing that decides their claims. Every carrier here sells a deductible, a reimbursement percentage and an annual limit, in much the same range. The orthopedic waiting period is not yours to choose, it varies from 14 days to six months across this list, and cruciate ligament rupture is the single most expensive common claim a dog makes.
That is the axis this comparison is built on. Published prices put a cruciate repair between 2,500 and 5,000 dollars a knee, higher at a referral hospital, and roughly doubled if the second leg goes, which it often does. A carrier that ringfences that condition for six months while a carrier next to it covers it in 14 days is selling a materially different product at a similar price.
The rest of what is worth paying for is exam fee cover, whether anyone will pay your vet directly, and what happens as the dog gets old.
What we weighted, and what we ignored
We read the policy forms and the carriers' own published terms rather than the comparison tables on their marketing pages, and where a carrier contradicted itself we say so instead of picking the friendlier version. Star ratings and satisfaction scores are ignored, because they measure the experience of people whose claims were paid, which is not the question. Headline prices are ignored as a ranking input too, since no two carriers publish a quote for the same dog and the profiles they choose are chosen to flatter. Where a carrier does publish a price with the dog and the plan settings attached, we quote it and name both.
The picks
Pets Best
The soundest all-round dog policy on the market and the one to start with. Exam fees are included as standard rather than sold back to you, optional Vet Direct Pay means the practice can be paid at the desk instead of you fronting a five-figure surgery, and there is no upper age limit and no reduction in coverage as the dog ages. The six-month cruciate wait is the weakness, and it is the most precisely waivable one here.
Plain link, no affiliate tracking on it yet.
- Annual limits
- 5,000 dollars to unlimited
- Deductible
- 100 to 1,000 dollars, annual
- Reimbursement
- 70, 80 or 90 percent
- Waits
- 3 days accident, 14 days illness, 6 months cruciate
- Exam fees
- Included, removable to cut the premium
What works
- Vet Direct Pay is optional on every plan, which very few carriers offer
- No upper enrollment age and no coverage reduction as the dog ages
- The cruciate waiver has the clearest rules of any carrier: exam from 3 days before to 7 days after the start date, form filed within 30 days
What to know
- Six-month cruciate wait everywhere else, which is the longest exposure on the most expensive dog claim
- Explicit bilateral exclusion: a pre-existing problem in one knee excludes the other
- From age three, dental illness cover requires an anesthetic cleaning within the previous thirteen months
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance
The best orthopedic terms in the market, and for a Labrador, Rottweiler or any dog whose knees are the thing you are insuring, that outranks everything else on this page. One 14-day waiting period covers accidents, illnesses and ligament and knee conditions alike. There is no separate orthopedic wait to serve and no exam to book to escape one. Exam fees are included and they will pay your vet directly if you ask.
Plain link, no affiliate tracking on it yet.
- Annual limits
- 2,500 dollars to unlimited
- Deductible
- 100, 250 or 500 dollars, annual
- Reimbursement
- 70, 80 or 90 percent
- Waits
- 14 days for everything, ligaments included
- Exam fees
- Included as standard
What works
- A single 14-day wait covering knee and ligament conditions, the best orthopedic term available
- Exam fees built in rather than sold as an add-on
- No upper enrollment age, and coverage is explicitly not reduced for senior dogs
- Will pay the veterinary practice directly when you elect it on the claim form
What to know
- Confirmed bilateral exclusion: a prior tear in one knee excludes the other
- Claims are processed in up to 30 days, the slowest turnaround on this list
- The only premium the site publishes is dated mid-2022 and tells you nothing about 2026 pricing
Spot Pet Insurance
The same 14-day-covers-everything structure as ASPCA, from the same underwriters, with exam fees included and no upper age limit. What separates it is that Spot publishes real quotes with the dog and the plan settings attached, which almost nobody else does. It loses to ASPCA on one point: Spot will not pay your vet directly, and the policy says plainly that the bill is between you and the practice.
Plain link, no affiliate tracking on it yet.
- Annual limits
- 2,500 dollars to unlimited
- Deductible
- Annual
- Reimbursement
- 70, 80 or 90 percent
- Waits
- 14 days for everything, ligaments included
- Exam fees
- Included on both plan types
- Published quote
- 41.76 dollars a month, 5.9-year large mixed breed, 250 dollar deductible, 90 percent, 5,000 dollar limit
What works
- No separate orthopedic waiting period, matching the best terms available
- Exam fees included on both the accident-only and accident-and-illness plans
- Publishes quotes with the dog profile and the plan settings stated, which makes them comparable
What to know
- No direct payment to the vet, so you carry every bill up front
- Curable pre-existing conditions return after 180 days, but knee and ligament conditions are carved out of that permanently
- The full deductible and limit menus are not published outside the quote flow
Embrace
Strong on the long game and weak in the first six months. Accident cover starts on day one, the curable pre-existing window is a reasonable 12 months, and a dog already insured keeps its accident-and-illness cover for life even past the point where new dogs of that age cannot buy it. The 180-day orthopedic wait in 42 states is the price of admission, which makes this a policy to buy for a puppy rather than for a five-year-old Labrador.
Plain link, no affiliate tracking on it yet.
- Annual limits
- 2,000 dollars to unlimited
- Deductible
- 200 to 1,000 dollars, annual
- Reimbursement
- 70, 80 or 90 percent
- Waits
- None for accidents, 14 days illness, 180 days orthopedic in 42 states
- Exam fees
- Optional paid add-on
- Age
- Accident and illness up to 14, accident-only from 15
What works
- Accident cover from day one, with no waiting period at all
- Dogs already enrolled keep accident-and-illness cover for life regardless of age
- Curable pre-existing conditions come back into cover after 12 symptom-free months
What to know
- A 180-day orthopedic waiting period in 42 states, covering cruciate disease, hip dysplasia, disc disease and patellar luxation
- Exam fees are a paid add-on rather than included
- You can lower your annual limit at any time but raising it means a new policy, and a new policy resets what counts as pre-existing
- No direct payment to the vet
MetLife Pet Insurance
The most adjustable policy here by a distance, and the right answer when the monthly figure has a hard ceiling. Deductibles run from zero upward in 50 dollar steps and limits in 1,000 dollar increments, so you can hit a target premium precisely instead of jumping between three preset tiers. There is no separate orthopedic waiting period and no per-incident cap. Read the Family Plan terms before you use it.
Plain link, no affiliate tracking on it yet.
- Annual limits
- 500 to 25,000 dollars in 1,000 dollar steps, plus unlimited
- Deductible
- 0 to 750 dollars in 50 dollar steps, then up to 2,500
- Reimbursement
- 50, 70, 80 or 90 percent
- Waits
- None for accidents, 14 days illness, no separate orthopedic wait
- Exam fees
- Covered
- Underwriter
- Metropolitan General Insurance Company
What works
- No separate orthopedic waiting period, so cruciate cover starts with everything else
- The finest premium tuning available: 50 dollar deductible steps and a 50 percent reimbursement tier nobody else sells
- No per-incident caps, and claims typically settle in about five days
What to know
- Does not pay veterinary practices directly, and says so plainly
- The Family Plan shares one deductible and one annual limit across up to three pets, so one sick dog can exhaust the household's cover
- Published prices are Florida averages with the breed and age undisclosed, so they are not comparable with anyone else's
How they compare
| Carrier | Orthopedic wait | Exam fees | Pays the vet directly | Upper enrollment age |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pets Best | 6 months, 30 days in 13 states | Included | Yes, optional on all plans | None |
| ASPCA Pet Health Insurance | 14 days | Included | Yes, if elected | None |
| Spot | 14 days | Included | No | None |
| Embrace | 180 days in 42 states | Paid add-on | No | 14 for accident and illness |
| MetLife | None separate | Covered | No | None stated |
| Trupanion | None | Excluded | Yes, at participating hospitals | 14 |
| Healthy Paws | Hip dysplasia excluded if enrolled at 6+ | Excluded | By prior arrangement | Not clearly published |
Four more worth knowing about
Trupanion is the structural outlier and deserves consideration for a dog with one expensive chronic problem ahead of it. There is no payout limit of any kind, the deductible applies once per condition for the animal's lifetime rather than annually, and reimbursement is 90 percent only. Its VetDirect Pay settles with the hospital at checkout where the practice runs the software, the best version of direct payment anyone offers. The trade is real: exam fees and preventive care are excluded, the illness wait is 30 days, an 18-month lookback on cruciate problems in either leg makes a prior issue pre-existing, and enrollment closes on the fourteenth birthday. Trupanion publishes no dog premium.
Healthy Paws has the reputation and the terms have moved. It now sells 5,000 dollar, 7,000 dollar and unlimited annual limits, and the limit can never be raised later. Exam fees are excluded outright, which the company states openly as the reason its premiums are lower. The clause to check is hip dysplasia: it is covered only for dogs enrolled before six years old with no signs in the first twelve months, which means a dog enrolled at six or older has no hip dysplasia cover at all. That is an exclusion rather than a wait, and for a large breed it is disqualifying.
Fetch includes exam fees at no extra cost and applies no breed restrictions or upper age limit. Its six-month orthopedic wait covers cruciate rupture, disc disease, patellar luxation and elbow and hip dysplasia, waivable by a vet exam within 180 days of enrollment. The claim submission window is 90 days, the tightest here, and Fetch publishes no sample policy, so the bilateral and per-condition terms cannot be read before you buy.
Lemonade is consistently among the cheapest and its own documents disagree about the thing that matters most. Its marketing states a 30-day orthopedic wait while its hosted policy disclosure states six months for cruciate ligament events. Both are Lemonade's. It also has breed-specific upper age limits it does not publish and does not pay vets directly. Get the cruciate answer in writing before buying it for a large dog.
Choosing in three questions
Is this a large or orthopedically risky breed? Then the orthopedic wait decides it, and ASPCA or Spot are the answers. If you prefer Pets Best for its direct payment, book the waiver exam in the week you buy and file the form inside 30 days.
Would fronting a five-figure bill be a problem? Then direct payment moves to the top and the shortlist is Pets Best, ASPCA or Trupanion. Reimbursement arrives weeks after the practice wants settling.
Is the dog already middle-aged? Then check the age terms before the price. Embrace stops selling accident-and-illness cover at 15, Trupanion stops enrolling at 14, and Healthy Paws drops hip dysplasia cover for anything enrolled at six or over. Age and pre-existing conditions will constrain you more than budget does.
Whatever you choose, the deductible, reimbursement and waiting period mechanics are worth understanding before you compare a single quote, and if you are still deciding whether to insure at all, we have run the cost arithmetic on both sides. For an older dog already showing stiffness, a joint problem in the record is an exclusion in waiting, which is its own argument for reading our guide to joint supplements for senior dogs.
Questions people actually ask
Which pet insurance has the shortest cruciate ligament waiting period?
Spot and ASPCA Pet Health Insurance apply a single 14-day waiting period that covers ligament and knee conditions with no separate orthopedic wait, and MetLife applies no separate orthopedic wait either. Pets Best, Fetch and Figo use six months, Embrace 180 days, and Healthy Paws excludes hip dysplasia entirely for dogs enrolled at six or older.
Can I get the orthopedic waiting period waived?
At most carriers that apply one, yes, with a clean veterinary examination. Pets Best requires the exam between three days before and seven days after the start date with the form filed within 30 days. Figo and Prudent Pet allow 30 days from the policy start, and Fetch allows 180 days. Book it the week you buy the policy.
Which pet insurers pay the vet directly?
Pets Best offers optional Vet Direct Pay on all plans, ASPCA Pet Health Insurance will pay the practice if you elect it on the claim form, Trupanion settles at checkout at hospitals running its software, and Healthy Paws will arrange it if set up before treatment. Spot, Embrace, MetLife, Fetch and Lemonade all reimburse you afterwards instead.
How much does dog insurance cost in 2026?
The US average accident-and-illness premium was 836 dollars a year, about 70 a month, in NAPHIA's 2026 report covering 2025. Breed and age move it far more than carrier choice does: the same policy prices at roughly 33 dollars a month for a Chihuahua and 129 for an Olde English Bulldogge, and a Labrador goes from about 44 a month at age one to 110 at age ten.
Does dog insurance cover hip dysplasia?
Usually, as a hereditary condition, but the waiting periods are the catch. Healthy Paws covers it only for dogs enrolled before age six and with no signs in the first twelve months, so a dog enrolled at six or older has no cover for it. Embrace, Pets Best, Fetch and Figo apply orthopedic waits of six months or 180 days that include hip dysplasia.
What is a bilateral exclusion?
A clause treating a paired body part as one condition. If your dog tore a cruciate ligament in one knee before enrollment, a bilateral exclusion means the other knee is excluded too. Pets Best and ASPCA both apply one. Healthy Paws limits it to cruciate ligaments and states that is the only bilateral exclusion in its policy.
Sources
- Pets Best: dog insurance plans
- ASPCA Pet Health Insurance: dog insurance
- Spot: dog insurance
- Embrace: dog insurance
- MetLife Pet Insurance: dog insurance
- Healthy Paws: frequently asked questions
- Fetch: what pet insurance covers
- NAPHIA State of the Industry Report 2026 highlights
- MoneyGeek: how much dog insurance costs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We earn a commission on some links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which products we recommend or the order they appear in. Full disclosure
Who wrote this
Marin Okafor
Editor, dog gear and nutrition labels
Marin Okafor edits PetGearSearch and writes the dog side of it: food, beds, crates, carriers, grooming tools, and the pet insurance policies that pay for the rest. The ingredient panel and the AAFCO statement get read before a single review does, because that back-of-bag paragraph is where two apparently identical foods stop being identical.
The standard
How this guide was built
- The full product specification, ingredient panel or material spec, read end to end rather than summarised from a retail listing.
- The veterinary and regulatory guidance that applies to the category, cited by name and linked — AAFCO nutrient profiles, WSAVA manufacturer guidelines, the VOHC accepted-product list.
- Aggregated owner reviews at volume across retailers, read for the pattern rather than the anecdote, with deliberate attention to the one-star reports where the failure modes live.
- Every price checked against the live listing on the date printed beside it.